Alec Bohm might be replaced on the hot corner by a costly slugger for the Phillies.
The Philadelphia Phillies have been a dominant force in Major League Baseball over the past few seasons, driven by a mix of established stars and emerging talent. One player who has consistently contributed to the team’s success in recent years is Alec Bohm, the third baseman who was drafted by the Phillies in 2018 and made his MLB debut in 2020. However, recent rumors and discussions surrounding the team’s future suggest that Bohm could face competition at his position, with the possibility that the Phillies may seek to replace him at the hot corner by acquiring a high-priced slugger.
Alec Bohm’s journey to the major leagues was a promising one. He was regarded as a top prospect, primarily for his hitting ability and strong offensive potential. Despite being drafted as a third baseman, Bohm’s early days in the majors have been marked by his inconsistent defensive play. While he has shown flashes of brilliance with his bat, his defense has been a concern, especially at a position as important as third base.
In his first few seasons with the Phillies, Bohm’s defense has been below average. Errors and misplays on routine ground balls have raised doubts about his long-term future at third base. In 2022, he posted a negative defensive runs saved (DRS) figure, highlighting his struggles with positioning and handling hard-hit balls. While Bohm has made some progress in his defensive game, his fielding issues continue to be a key talking point.
Offensively, however, Bohm has proven to be a valuable contributor for the Phillies. He has demonstrated solid contact skills, with a good batting average and on-base percentage. His power, while not elite, is solid, and he has the potential to develop more pop as he matures as a hitter. In 2023, Bohm hit .280 with 16 home runs and 74 RBIs, showcasing his ability to produce runs and provide consistency in the lineup. Despite these positive offensive numbers, the question remains whether his bat alone can make up for his defensive struggles.
As the Phillies aim to continue competing for championships, their front office has been proactive in exploring ways to improve the roster, especially in terms of their infield defense. Reports have surfaced that the team is looking at high-priced, power-hitting third baseman to bolster the hot corner. The idea of adding a slugger to replace Bohm is not entirely out of the realm of possibility, given that the Phillies have the financial resources to make a splash in free agency or the trade market.
One name that has frequently come up in trade discussions is All-Star third baseman Nolan Arenado of the St. Louis Cardinals. Arenado is widely regarded as one of the best defensive third basemen of his generation, and his bat is just as dangerous. Over his career, he has won nine Gold Gloves and earned multiple Silver Slugger awards. While Arenado’s defense is arguably better than Bohm’s, it is his power and run-producing abilities that make him a sought-after commodity. Arenado’s bat has consistently produced 30+ home runs and 100+ RBIs per season, numbers that the Phillies would welcome in their lineup. Although acquiring Arenado would require significant financial commitment and a trade package that could include young talent, it could be the kind of bold move the Phillies need to solidify their position as a World Series contender.
Another possibility is the Phillies making a run at Matt Chapman of the Toronto Blue Jays. Chapman, like Arenado, is known for his elite defense at third base, as well as his consistent power at the plate. Over the past few seasons, Chapman has been a reliable 30-homer threat and a force in the middle of the lineup. With a strong defensive reputation and a proven ability to hit for power, Chapman would be a perfect fit for the Phillies’ needs. He’s not as decorated as Arenado but still one of the premier third basemen in the league. While Chapman may not come as high-priced as Arenado, he would still command a hefty contract, making him a costly acquisition for the Phillies.
From a financial standpoint, the Phillies have the resources to pull off such a move. After reaching the World Series in 2022 and staying competitive in 2023, the team’s ownership has shown a willingness to spend to win. The addition of stars like Bryce Harper and Trea Turner, combined with significant contracts handed out to players like J.T. Realmuto and Zack Wheeler, has demonstrated that the Phillies are committed to spending money to bolster their roster. Therefore, bringing in a high-priced slugger to replace Bohm at third base would not be out of the question.
In terms of player development, the Phillies have a solid minor league system that could offer up prospects in a trade for an established player. While Bohm is a valuable part of the Phillies’ current roster, the team might consider moving him to a different position or even trading him to improve the team in other areas. The Phillies’ minor league system has depth, with several talented prospects who could be attractive trade chips in any potential deal.
That said, the Phillies may ultimately decide to stick with Bohm at third base and give him more time to improve his defense. After all, Bohm is still relatively young, and many players take time to adjust to the demands of a major league position. With continued development, he could become an above-average defender at third base while maintaining his offensive production. His consistency at the plate has made him a valuable contributor to the team, and a few minor adjustments in his defensive game could help him solidify his spot as the long-term answer at third base.
In conclusion, while Alec Bohm’s position with the Phillies is not entirely secure, the team faces a challenging decision in balancing his offensive contributions with his defensive shortcomings. The idea of replacing Bohm with a high-priced slugger such as Nolan Arenado or Matt Chapman is a possibility, given the team’s financial resources and need for an upgrade at the hot corner. However, the Phillies may also decide to stay patient with Bohm, allowing him time to develop defensively while continuing to produce at the plate. Regardless of the decision, the Phillies will have to weigh their options carefully as they continue to pursue championship aspirations.
